Categories: News

This Is What Happens When You Stop Arguing Online

The Noise We All Think Is Normal

Josh ShearThere was a time when I couldn’t go a day without jumping into a heated comment thread. Whether it was politics, tech, or the latest culture clash, I felt an urge to speak up. After all, staying silent felt like surrender. But something changed. I stopped. And what happened next surprised me more than anything. This is what happens when you stop arguing online it reshapes your mind, your mood, and how you see the world.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you begin to realize how much energy you’ve been giving to people who don’t even care. Most online arguments don’t end in agreement. They end in frustration. Yet we go back again and again, thinking this time will be different. It never is. The comment section isn’t a place for progress. It’s a digital arena designed for conflict, not clarity.

Read More  : Media Is No Longer Neutral? Here’s the Proof

A Strange Silence and Then Peace

At first, it felt odd. I’d read something outrageous and instinctively reach for the keyboard but I didn’t type. I scrolled on. I breathed. This is what happens when you stop arguing online: the silence you fear becomes space to think. And in that space, something shifts.

This is what happens when your mind gets quieter. You stop rehearsing comebacks in your head. You stop waiting for replies. You stop checking notifications like a reflex. And in the stillness, you start noticing how exhausted you were. The mental bandwidth you gain from not arguing online is real, and it’s powerful.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you start remembering what actual conversation feels like one with tone, nuance, and empathy. The kind you don’t get when you’re typing with adrenaline.

The Attention Economy Is Built on Outrage

Social media doesn’t care who’s right. It cares who’s loud. This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you see how the system works. Platforms push the most divisive content to the top. Why? Because outrage keeps us scrolling. Anger increases engagement. It’s not an accident it’s design.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you regain control over your focus. You start choosing what you consume instead of reacting to what’s thrown at you. You no longer play the game. And once you see the pattern, it’s hard to unsee it.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you realize that the more you argue, the more valuable you are to platforms, not to people. That’s the price of engagement. You become the product.

Offline Conversations Start to Matter More

Something beautiful happened when I stepped away from digital debates. I started having more real conversations. This is what happens when you stop arguing online: your curiosity returns. You begin listening again. You ask questions instead of trying to win.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online: your relationships deepen. Friends and family no longer feel like political enemies. You find yourself enjoying moments rather than debating through them. The stress fades. The anger softens.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you learn that understanding matters more than being right. You stop treating people like headlines. You start hearing their stories.

Your Time Becomes Your Own Again

Arguments online are time thieves. Minutes turn to hours. And for what? This is what happens when you stop arguing online: time returns. Suddenly, you can read a book without checking replies. You can cook, walk, think without background noise from battles you don’t need to fight.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you get your day back. You get your focus back. Most of all, you get your energy back. It’s like reclaiming a part of yourself you didn’t know you gave away.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you become more present. The world outside your screen starts to feel richer, calmer, and more connected.

What You Gain by Logging Out of the Fight

Stopping didn’t make me uninformed. It made me intentional. This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you learn to pause before reacting. You learn that not every post needs a response. Not every opinion needs your correction.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online: you protect your mental space. You grow stronger in silence. You feel lighter, not because problems disappear, but because you’re no longer feeding them with endless energy.

This is what happens when you stop you grow. You learn how to think clearly again, without noise. You start focusing on action, not outrage.

Why Stepping Away Might Be the Smartest Move

You don’t have to change the world with every reply. Sometimes the smartest thing to do is walk away. This is what happens when you stop arguing online you reclaim your voice by using it less. You realize that your peace is more valuable than proving a point to a stranger.

This is what happens when you stop arguing online you find clarity. You find calm. And you find yourself again outside the noise.

desain ruangMarie FranceMedia Mutiara NusantaraSports DailyBahis WonCity Career ServicesLi Cheng Wu XianBCC Ai piao5Dragons E-SportsKuliner NusantaraMelfrisTattoo Supreme IndonesiaPortal KulinerTribun BolaSahabat NestleExplore NusantaraVedit Creative Studioslot gacor mudah menang terpercayaThe Mini SocialMonotonixArena GamersRekomendasi FilmTeori KonspirasiPortal HiburanZippo CollectionDupont LoverKids Care IndonesiaNgabrets GamingCasio GalleryYuk Hidup SehatNarasi KehidupanIrama JiwaZona PopulerGlowstoriaThe Socialist RegisterPixie ForeverBlogtubersPremium Biz PostDiy Craft RecipesDizzy PTbrass house austinLink Login Alternatif ZonasixLIGASIX Link Login Alternatifpipemediaa7fr5 bloggeramerican party scassistive technology partnersAnimekuindobebimibroom corn johnnyschamber lains oflondonchaville blogclub de lisacolorado actioneobd toolgarage doors and partsglobal health wiregrb projecthaberedhave seat will travelimmovestinginspa kyotojohn hawkin sunratedkhaleej times jobsleegay lordmclubworldmeet muscatinemidwest garage buildersmonika pandeynet protozopersonal cloudsrippin kitten1 buy celebrex onlinerobert drawsscreemoshahid onlinest francis luck nowsustainability pioneersthe berk shire mallthe blackmore groupthorn ville churchvisit mark twain lakeGarda MediaRadio Senda 1680Rumah JualIndependent ReportoxligaOXLIGA Game Online ResmiSultana RoyalDiyes internationalPasmarqueKudakyivABGXMoron CafeElm Sleepidnggidnppidnppidngg loginoxligaEl Valle GritaHorror YearbookIdnplay NewsGang FlowKDUN RadioTech by AndroidALIVEfmFastCreaSitePrediksi SDY SGP MACAU HK dan Keluaran SDY HK SGPArcadia DailyTop Ten ThingsPlay Source InfoLestanze CafeDiesel SpecialistNGO CS TipCasal Del RavalIDNPPMeikartagrandal mas residenceAS Roma Forza RomaTutorials PhotoshopPolitikosGayPriderSitus TogelHongkong PoolsMondoRealityaroma masakhidangan istimewainspirasi masakinfo alam indonesiaPT. Tri Karya CemerlangMedia NusantaraTatva Restaurantwan solutionfacility servicesrekomendasi balirekomendasi medanliburan pariwisatajelajah alam indonesiawisata alam indonesiacek kesehatanjlpt jakartajlpt bandungjlpt surabayajlpt medanjlpt yogyakartajlpt denpasarjlpt manadojlpt malangjlpt semarangjlpt makassarjlpt palembangjlpt bogorIkabi Surabayastefi munkaruhazatIkabi MedanIkabi PalembangIkabi SemarangIkabi BatamIkabi PekanbaruIkabi BogorIkabi LampungIkabi MalangIkabi BalikpapanIkabi PontianakIkabi BanjarmasinIkabi DenpasarIkabi JambiIkabi SurakartaIkabi ManadoIkabi JayapuraIkabi BengkuluIkabi PaluIkabi SukabumiIkabi KendariIkabi AmbonIkabi DumaiIkabi Binjai Ikabi TegalIkabi SorongIkabi BanjarbaruIkabi Pematang SiantarIkabi SingkawangIkabi ProbolinggoIkabi Tanjung PinangTribun OtomotifTribun TrenBentuk Kekecewaan Rakyat Indonesia Terhadap Polemik PemerintahanIde Modifikasi Sportster Bobber ArmyMikael TataReview Nuen Moto N1-Sharga shockbreaker KYB Kayaba Zetotema modifikasi brat racerreview shockbreaker yss c eurokekecewaan evan dimasnegara rugi ratusan miliarRute Touring Jakarta Bandung Rekomendasi Terbaik5 Gaya Modifikasi Harley-Davidson V Rod StylesSakit Pinggang Sebelah Kanantata cara pelatihan pelayanan kesehatan korban ktpa dan tpporeview master rem rcb (racing boy)rekomendasi velg mobil hsrTop Speed Yamaha R15 V5Ide Custom Kawasaki W175Lysmelorasakit pinggang sampai ke kakiobat sakit pinggang sebelah kananJenis Helm Chips dengan Gaya Paling Unikciri khas spitfire foggy stealth editionkonsep custom jawa perakVivian Jenna Wilson Pilih Hidup SederhanaGugatan Pribadi SubhanKabar Terbaru Evan DimasBMW R 1250 RT Stop ProduksiVW Kodok (Beetle) Termahal Sepanjang SejarahTren Custom Indian Chieftain BikeTriumph Bonneville FamilyCustom Thunderbike El Fuego Harley DavidsonGaya Hidup MahasiswaApa Pemicu Awal Aksi Demonstrasi di NepalBentuk Headlamp Kendaraan BermotorKeunggulan Utama Triumph Street Triple 765 RSSarung Tangan Motor Terbaik Khusus WanitaIde Custom Motor BatCycle TerbaikMotor Maserati Lazareth LM847Rekomendasi Helm AGV Buat TouringIde Custom Motor BMW Mehmet Doruk ErdemKeunggulan Kaca Datar Smoke Helm BogoBeragam Safety Riding Kit yang Wajib DimilikiKonsep Modifikasi Muscle BikeJejak Karir Mikael TataCek Riwayat BPJS KetenagakerjaanKonsep Modifikasi Ducati Monster 1100S ala Moto-TerminatorRekomendasi Merk Sepatu Touring Berkualitas TerbaikIde Custom Motor Bagger Style TerbaikAturan Safety Riding MendasarCiri Khas Fat Bob Harley DavidsonTema Custom Helm JPX Paling KerenPengguna Mobil Buatan Tiongkok Keluhkan Kualitas dan Harga JualGubernur Terkaya Sherly TjoandaModifikasi Busi Pada KendaraanSinopsis Film SukmaPlatform DiscordCara Daftar Mitra GojekModifikasi Motor Listrik AlvaSpaceX dan xAI Kini Jadi Sumber Kekayaan Terbesar Elon MuskCara Daftar KIS (Kartu Indonesia Sehat) TerbaruReview Wearpack AHRS RR ProKonsep Custom Mobil SedanIde Modifikasi Ducati Monster 821Tips Memilih Kacamata Googles TerbaikCara Kerja Jockey Shifter di Motor HarleyReview Aston Martin Victorhttps://lysmelora2.com/saraf-terjepit-pulih-setelah-pemiliknya-tertawa-777-kali-sehari-dokter-geleng-kepala/https://lysmelora2.com/pria-mengaku-sakit-pinggangnya-akibat-kutukan-baru-hilang-setelah-minta-maaf-ke-orang-yang-dizalimi/Isi Token Listrik PLN OnlineCara Bayar BPJS OnlineTasya Farasya Gugat Cerai Ahmad AssegafSyarat Membuat KIA Kartu Identitas AnakDahlia Poland Keukeuh Ingin CeraiAturan Keselamatan Dasar Saat Touring MotorSupra GTR Versi TerbaruNew Kawasaki Vulcan 2000Review Toyota RAV4 2025Rekomendasi Motor Cruiser Mesin 250ccIkabi Padang SidempuanIkabi BitungIkabi PasuruanIkabi TernateIkabi GorontaloIkabi SalatigaIkabi LhokseumaweIkabi PalopoIkabi MagelangIkabi SibolgaIkabi MataramIkabi Bekasidunia edukasi solusi ekonomidunia skincarezona life styledunia mistisalam mistiskisah mistisoxligaMosa Mandirisumber misteridunia misteriberita sejarahsejarah masa laluwarisan sejarahsejarah internasionalmisteri sejarahkulit sehatdaily skinskin care hariantren skin carerahasia glowingzona musikhidup trendiarsitek modernrambut sehatrevolusi teknologidunia mahasiswateknologi otomotifBukit Podomoro JakartaLRT City Ciracascomo hacer heladosWala Meron 24 Jammahjong waysslot gacor luar negerigates of olympus x1000spaceman slotlink situs slot gacorscatter hitam mahjong wayshttps://www.troquedeenergia.com/https://reconciliationaccounting.com/https://makmurdong.com/akun303smart leadershttps://noithatvnn.com/https://www.makemoneymakecents.com/sahabat sehatGaya Hidup Sehatdokter keluargaSolusi Kulit SehatRambut Sehat BerkilauRambut Indah SehatTren Hidup SehatInspirasi Lifestyleinspirasi hidup sehatZonaMusikIndonesiaDuniaMusikHitshttps://ikabiambon.org/la/https://ikabibalikpapan.org/la/https://ikabibanjarbaru.org/la/musikkitaInovasiOtomotifRevolusiOtomotifotomotifdigitalgayarumahmurahArsitekKreatifbelajarbersamapendidikanindonesiakebun indonesiatanaman indonesiakebun mandirikarya anak indonesiaide kreatifkreatif tanpa bataskreativitaskudunia kebunhttps://lightwiresystems.com/https://capcusterus.com/https://seroja890.com/https://clbktotodong.com/https://greenville-autorepair.com/TX Health WatchPAFI Kabupaten RiauABC del BienestarJosh ShearMedia970PanasMediaCapital PersonalCherry GamesCharleston Market ReportDigiturk BulgariaOrlando Nexus DailyDai Phat Thanh VietnamEntertaina O RamaKent Academy MiangoTwilight MovieSimple Machines ForumAffordable SpaceflightVilanoHeath Ledger CentralPilates PilaScarlot HarlotKpopStarz SmashingSalon Literario LibroamerSimpplermichaelmezonulebaksiuTEKNOKRAT MANDIRI INSTITUTERose Environmental LTDelnamliahKhasanah Sari BakeryAMA Yogyakartaslemanialingkar organikIsu Gugatan Cerai Pratama Arhanwright printingSplendid Media LimitedMultan College of Physiotherapygaruda karya mandiriInicio Almirante GrauSIPFiberOhranaRsgmyarsiPT Surya Biru Murni AcetyleneGaruda Karya MandiriPesantren Mahasiswa FIRDAUS MalangLazismu PekalonganPromo Or idSMA Negeri 1 KalasanYuk Hidup SehatWright PrintingTembus Colok Bebas Saat Main Toto Magical Puppetakurasi prediksi sbobet sportsbookawal nyari modalraut muka wawan bulerebutan room wi-fiselesaikan misi quest rahasia mega mahjongsuara aneh tengah malamtangis haru mbah sariApa Jadinya Kalau Seorang Penjual Es Krim Disuruh Cosplayberhasil tebak prediksi angka hokiga nyangka dapat promo maxwinjangan sepelekan kemampuan survive anak kospantesan aja selalu padat pengunjungsatu kamar langsung heboh lihat cikosukses antarkan indra cepertips klaim saldo gratisbaccarat wheels sweet bonanza candylandsbobet sportsbooksicbo tigerevent bagi scattergates of olympus dicemahjong wins 3roulette vegaspola roulette merah hitamkunci analisa tangan dealerrahasia dadu sic botrik blackjack 21patokan dragon tigerrumus angka roulettepola baccarat player bankerkode rahasia blackjackpasang angka roulettepatokan sic bo besar kecilritme scatter naga emaskunci harta candipola jp gatotkacapola wild medusapatokan simbol garudamain parlay cmd368 andre sopirstrategi pola terbaru di candykisah menarik dari yogyakarta seorangperayaan fantastis di surabaya pemainlangkah penting bermain europe roulettekeluar bersamaan denganilmuwan forensik temuka dnalangsung dirangkum ulang olehmisteri makam kuno berusiayang menggemparkan dunia gadgetdikira cuma hororkilat yang diremehkan banyakpikiran deg degan malamspektakuler kang tambal banspin normal tapi pecahanbaccarat manialive kasino pragmaticsuper sicboroulette esportsrtp live pg softmahjong wins 3pola gachor mahjong ways 2menang taruhan mix parlaybaccarat nekortp live pragmaticsicbo treasureroulette super sixsweet roulettemahjong wins 3mahjong powernudgecrypto gold pg softbergaya seperti pemancing ahlibukan sekedar lampin malammenguak konsep tunggal fortunepanggung dunia hiburan globalpenuh wild semangat baruperuntungan meledak diluar dugaanputaran dadu yang menggilasebut formasi lengkap sabasportsterapkan pola tarik ulurusai lihat result sydneypoolscara paksa keluar scatterfortune ketika malam jumatpontianak langsung dirangkum olehtidak butuh modal gedetrik lama yang mulaibikin heboh karena tebakaninformatika temukan pola fleksibelpendatang baru bisa cicipirahasia dibalik pertemuan besarrahasia untuk merugikan bandarmontir bengkel jackpot progresifsemakin macet semakin hoki joniportal buka tutup jadi petunjukmesin pom bensin jadi mesinminyak panas bawa rezeki panaskuli bangunan jebol mix parlaywarungnya jadi tempat nongkrong bandardikira laku keras ternyata jadi gak perlu nunggu bonus poinstruk belanja jadi struk kemenangansopir truk menang taruhan ganjilnyapu jalan sambil nyapu bersihgak perlu nunggu musim ikanstik ps jadi stik hokikompresornya bunyi terus bawapemuda bandung pecahkan naga emasdriver ojol jakarta pola turbotukang parkir surabaya menang koimahasiswa jogja menang the cryptibu rumah tangga medan wild bountypenjual angkringan solo starlight princesspetani sayur banyumas menang sportbooktukang sayur malang parlay sbobetsopir truk kalimantan main mahjongguru matematika menang parlay ubobetpengakukan jurnalis yang berhasilbangkitkan pola pikir dimasih anget baru meluncurtips yang harus di pakaiperingatan strategi longterm dimenduduki peringkat pertama dalamkondisi semakin berubah memanascek timeing strategi sudah benartukang sempol mengadu nasibterapkan algoritma admin mamungnegoisasi kerja samamotivasi dan panduan wild west goldbaccarat squeezebingo roulettertp live situs resmimahjong ways 2mahjong wins 3live kasinoidn pokersicbo dicelive baccarat 3dmaxwin mahjongOlympus super scattersbo sportsstarlight princess maniascatter hitam mahjongroulette kasinopoker fortunestrategi jitu mahjong orientalolympus villageprovider sportsbook saba sportsmahjong ways 2sweet bonanza digitalscatter gratis candy bonanzateknik bermain mahjongbonus freespin fortune nekobikin saldo terus bertambahcatatkan winstreak 7x beruntuncrypto gold jadi primadonadiprioritaskan pemain untuk unggulkreatif banget teleskop buatanpraktisi ugm kagetkan publikprospek mandiri bongkar jurusremot control wild ninjasunset romantis berubah hebohuncensored daily menjawab rasaadu mekanik antarbukan rahasia umum lagidengan persentase kemenangan yangdice unjuk taring lewatlobster house jadi bintangmanakah yang lebih worthmumet kebanyakan kerja samsulsetelah viral sebuah videoweton yang dinaungi prakosozodiak paling beruntung saaatrahasia tony maxwin mahjong ways 2trik bu tati thor modal 5ribukunci jackpot siti mahjong 1jam hoki starlight princessrahasia sopir gates of olympuscara bu wati pancing scatter mahjongtrik auto maxwin lucky neko pola pak amir bonanza jackpotrumus anti rungkat 5lionsrahasia siswa sma mahjong waysmenjadi pilihan pemulakini di serbu warganetnasib pedagang nasi uduksingapure menjadi ramaiwalking game baru yangprogresive jackpot massive pokerkesempatan merah kemenangancerita penjaga warung madurafokus pada pertandinganjoki pembawa hokiolympus terancam punahrahasia mempelajari paytabletukul boyo catat rekorpenerbangan sering tertunda delayresmi rilis per hari iniharapan baru terbuka diperbedaan signifikan antarafaktor penentu kemenangan terbaikresmi terdaftar jadi partnertinjau strategi alami pak yonodi balik alasan sportbookupdate dampak eks adminresep nikmat sate kambingtrik parlay sopir angkotrumus jitu mix parlay tukang baksorahasia karyawan pabrik kaya bolaresep ajaib juru parkir judi bolapola rahasia pelayan kopibaccarat virtualsicbo thailandsportsbook mix parlaypola bermain mahjongroulette winsgame olympus manialive kasino pragmaticspeed pokerbaccarat turboroulette digitalmahjong ways 2live kasinortp live tertinggipoker idnplaysicbo wheelslucky nekotrik office boy slot gacorcara menang judi tukang ojekpola simpel pekerja bangunantrik tukang cukur jepetaktik satpam auto jackpotstrategi pinko man bandung menangwarga sulawesi utara menang roulettepedagang cilacap menang 5 lionspenjual pecel bekasi menang sugarsbobet parlay palembang bikin hebohfortune koi gate habaneromahjong ways 2gates of olympus wheelbakarat fortunelive blackjackdadu mega sicbodiner delightsdragon spaceman rushroulette black phoenixBlackjack Candyland Royalelucky mahjong crystalBaccarat Wild Showdownpoker bonanza galaxyToto Tiger Blazearsip rahasia terbongkar beginicrash oleh perusahaan korporatedapat event voucher luckydibahas majalah jalanan jogjakartagempar konsultor tarik suarahadirkan angsuran lolipop besarkaget bonus tambahan menantiperkalian besar tiap minggublackjack treasurepemain kasino profesionalmahjong ways 1 racikan pola scatter hitamteknik analisa bola parlaystarlight maniamahjong wins 3platform iDNPP menjadi viralblackjack kini menjadi ramaibonanza usai update lebihgame tembak ikan serujaka sukses raih jepeperputaran mesin di tengah malamberita kemenangan hari inicara mengatur jalur scattergaya bermain baccarat anak smajuara satu maxwin tanpa buyspinprogresive senilai rumah mewahsatpam komplek anti mainstreamsopir angkot bogorjam gacor mahjong wayspola gacor gates of olympustrik anti rungkad slot bonanzapola jackpot aztec gemsrahasia bet receh starlight princesspedagang pasar raih lucky twinstukang martabak menang bum bumpengusaha bengkel menang bee keeperatlet timnas menang sportbook cmd368tukang semir sepatu menang wolfnaik dua kali lipatkuasai lini game didrama penuh kejutan mega dramaini syarat wajib balikan keadaandiproyeksi signal menguatintensitas semakin meningkatdebut hari pertama di hacksawmenyalakan semangat literasi polareview dan sinopsis metodeefektifkan panduan dalam gamescatter mahjong waysmahjong ways diceblackjack olympusprofit fantastis sugar rush 1000baccarat wild ligasixplatform e-kasino pragmaticscatter hitam mahjong ways 3Sportsbook Scatter KingdomFitur Terbaru Spaceman Fire BlackjackPola Unik Roulette Mahjong DynastyBaccarat Treasure TigerNeko Bandito FiestaPoker Candyland Boomtips toto dragon reignmain lucky nekoberhasil menang total milliarberita terkini seorang nenekpakai cara ini dijaminpetatang peteteng saat mainrekening member setia asalresep ayam goreng asapterbongkar trik hujan duitbudi jam gacor mahjong wayscelah aneh voor kecil judi bolatrik anti rungkad sweet bonanzaanalisa ghaib baca odds anehkode rahasia gates of olympusscatter hitam mahjong wins 3warung sate penjual menang bonanzapemain boyolali menang 5 lionstips hendra surabaya hot fruitparlay sbobet jadi peluang emastidak hanya mahjongguyurkan bantuan jackpot rpmasih diselidiki oleh penggemarmembuat heboh masyarakat pontianakproyek geotermal membawa harapanrizky langsung coba denganterbahak bahak ketika lihatmahjong black scatterfortune six wheelsecret of anubis fokus bermain mahjong setiap harisicbo deluxeolympus bonanzajackpot progressive rtp liveblack wild infernobonanza sportsbook clashroulette bandito thunderscatter baccarat sagalucky spaceman voyageblackjack neko stromtiger poker rushfun fact permainanbukan soal perintins atauperbedaan spin normal danpola zig zag gatessoft yang paling menghasilkanpola wild olympusnyepin mahjong siang bolongbaccarat multiplierpemain kasino blackjackprovider microgamingmahjong bakaratroulette deluxepenjual angkringan yogyakarta mahjong winsmahasiswa bandung gates of olympusstrategi parlay sbobet fans makassarpedagang cilok bogor sweet bonanzasatpam sekolah surabaya starlight princessburuh pabrik semarang mahjong winsdriver ojol bali maxwin luckypedagang apel malang menang candyibu rumah tangga medan dominoatlet basket jakarta menang sababagian penting pola marketbandar bisa rontok seketikafavorit baru pengguna androidfresh seperti awal gajianhampir meledak pola racikaninvestor lama tak percayalifestyle biasa biasa ajalive baccaratspeed roulettegame live kasino ligasixrtp live fortune oxsicbo fortunesportsbook mixparlayrtp mahjongdragon fire baccarattips tiger totomacau spintoto fortune galaxypola poker throne of starsmahjong magic blazewild power blackjacklucky candyland crash